I’m working on a new domain and I think about to use discourse as forum software.
On other domains I use Woltlab and Vanilla … but discourse is getting more and more popular.
You’ll have to decide on what you’d rather spend: money or time. DigitalOcen has compatible machines for $20/month, while the smallest Discourse plan is $100/month. That’s almost a difference of $1000/year.
I guess if you’re doing server administration already, then adding one more wouldn’t be a big hassle. Otherwise the hosted option could end up being cheaper.
+1 for DigitalOcean. I’ve got a Discourse up on there and it’s much more cost effective than AWS - while our community is small (<100 users, with ~25 active), our post index is huge, as the forum dates back 15+ years (150k posts). The specs for the money at DO made a lot of sense.
I find Discourse with its Javascript sickness rather disturbing, especially since its structure (categories are not the default view…?) makes it incredibly hard to find what you’re looking for.
I don’t get the hype and I hope it will be over soon.