Permalink are same on pagination pages

support
1

Not sure if this is by designed or a bug, paginaton pages’ Permalink (RelPermalink) are same.

// layouts/index.html
{{ range .Paginator.Pages }}
  {{ warnf "%s" .Title }}
{{ end }}

{{ warnf "[%s] page number: %d" .Permalink .Paginator.PageNumber }}

paginate is set as 1.

hugo

WARN  A
WARN  [https://example.org/] page number: 1
WARN  B
WARN  [https://example.org/] page number: 2
WARN  C
WARN  [https://example.org/] page number: 3
2

Mind the context

The loop renders index html three times,

but your second warn is outside any paginator loop

so .Permalink has the index.html as context

3

Yep, however I’m questioning about the pagination pages, the second warn should be correct.

Page Permalink
https://example.org/ https://example.org/
https://example.org/page/2 https://example.org/
https://example.org/page/3 https://example.org/

I’m not sure if the pagination page’s Permalink should be similar the follows, or it’s theme author’s duty to use .Paginator.URL instead of Permalink in this case.

Page Permalink
https://example.org/ https://example.org/
https://example.org/page/2 https://example.org/page/2
https://example.org/page/3 https://example.org/page/3
4

What you call “Pagination Page” is IMHO not available

from the docs at: Paginate | Hugo

Pagination is the process of splitting a list page into two or more pagers, where each pager contains a subset of the page collection and navigation links to other pagers.

So at this stage

  • there is no Page but only ONE Pager object which offers Pager methods | Hugo to deal with it’s pageSets.

  • the current context “.” of the rendered Page (index.md) is unchanged.

    You already noticed that by using .Paginator.PageNumber and not just .PageNumber in your warnf Statement.

This is a Design/Implementation decision

There are plenty of reasons I can think of why that has been done… but I wont guess here

1 Like
5

See https://github.com/gohugoio/hugo/issues/4507.

This is one of the top 10 upvoted issues.

1 Like
6

If you do this, make sure you do it AFTER paginating the page collection.

1 Like
7

This may be a minor issue for some embeded templates, such as Twitter cards, I guess.

8

This topic was automatically closed 2 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.